cyberneticlibrary

Convene AI personas to debate questions

meeting-botspluginsetup L23,035
davepoon/buildwithclaude
What it does

Debate a question with 5+ AI personas representing different perspectives

Best for

Product teams making high-stakes decisions who want to systematically surface disagreements and explore tradeoffs without group-think bias.

Inputs
  • · question or decision to debate
  • · participant count (3-10 personas)
  • · team composition (dev, design, product, business, life, custom)
Outputs
  • · structured debate transcript with turns
  • · consensus points (if any)
  • · disagreement summary (key tensions identified)
  • · recommendation (aggregate of persona votes)
Preconditions
  • · question sufficiently complex to benefit from multi-perspective debate
  • · team composition clearly defined
Failure modes
  • · personas converge too quickly — debate ends prematurely
  • · personas dominated by one voice — limited genuine disagreement
  • · question ambiguous — personas interpret differently, debate becomes tangential
  • · recommendation unclear — personas deadlocked
Trust signals
  • · diverse persona library (dev, design, product, business, life, custom)
  • · explicit disagreement capture
  • · vote aggregation for recommendation
  • · debate transcript (auditable reasoning)