cyberneticlibrary

Review feature design and append findings

copilot-review-designcommandsetup L113
mattshma/code-copilot
What it does

Review feature design against CLAUDE.md standards and append findings

Best for

Getting a second review of a feature design before implementation to catch architectural or scope issues

Inputs
  • · Feature spec directory path (e.g., docs/specs/auth-flow)
  • · design.md file from that directory
  • · Existing review-design.md with prior rounds
Outputs
  • · Findings appended to review-design.md (Issues, Suggestions, Confirmations sections)
  • · DESIGN APPROVED marker if no blocking issues remain
Requires
  • · Read (CLAUDE.md, design.md, review-design.md)
  • · Write (append only to review-design.md)
Preconditions
  • · CLAUDE.md exists in project root
  • · design.md exists in $ARGUMENTS directory
  • · review-design.md can be created if missing
Failure modes
  • · $ARGUMENTS path does not exist
  • · design.md not found in specified directory
  • · Attempted to modify existing review-design.md content (append-only requirement)
Trust signals
  • · Append-only to review-design.md (prevents losing discussion history)
  • · Checks CLAUDE.md standards explicitly (not style preferences)
  • · Tracks round numbers to prevent re-raising resolved issues
  • · Distinguishes blocking (must fix) from non-blocking (suggestion)
  • · Escalates to human if round 3+ with issues remain