cyberneticlibrary

Validate decisions with consensus panel

validate-consensuscommandsetup L140
gonzalezpazmonica/pm-workspace
What it does

Run three-judge consensus panel to validate specs, PRs, and decisions

Best for

High-stakes design decisions where independent expert review reduces blind spots

Inputs
  • · type (spec|pr|decision)
  • · ref (file_path_or_pr_number)
  • · judges (1|2|3)
Outputs
  • · verdict (APPROVED|CONDITIONAL|REJECTED)
  • · score (0-1)
  • · per-judge_reasoning
  • · dissent_log
Requires
  • · Read
  • · Bash
  • · Glob
  • · Write
Preconditions

Spec/PR/decision file must exist; at least 1 judge available

Failure modes

Veto triggered but not addressed, timeout >120s, less than 2 judges selected

Trust signals
  • · Three independent judges (reflection-validator, code-reviewer, business-analyst)
  • · Explicit veto mechanism
  • · Audit trail per execution