Critique PR review for accuracy
review-the-reviewcommandsetup L1★204
wheels-dev/wheels ↗What it does
Critique bot reviewer output for bias and accuracy
Best for
Secondary review gate: catch sycophancy, false positives, and missed issues in bot reviews; converge on approve/request-changes/defer via up to 10 rounds.
Inputs
- · PR number
- · review ID
- · commit SHA
Outputs
- · PR comment with critique
- · convergence marker if aligned
Requires
- · gh CLI
Preconditions
- · PR exists
- · Reviewer A (bot) review exists
- · GitHub access
Failure modes
- · round cap reached without convergence
- · reviewer is not the bot
- · PR diff retrieval fails
Trust signals
- · 3-part critique (sycophancy/false-positives/missed-issues)
- · round counting prevents infinite loops
- · convergence markers trigger next stage