cyberneticlibrary

Panel judge architecture decisions

mishkan-architecture-panelworkflowsetup L33
Y4NN777/mishkan-cc-harness
What it does

Judge panel for an architecture decision: 3 Nathan runs from different priors propose alternatives; Zadok/Phinehas/Shallum score impact in parallel; main session synthesises the winner.

Best for

Design decisions where reasoning needs three competing priors evaluated in parallel.

Inputs
  • · structured data
Outputs
  • · design document
Requires
  • · Claude Code agent runtime (parallel/fan-out)
  • · subagent execution
  • · JSON schema validation
Preconditions
  • · Artifact must conform to specified schema
  • · Claude Code workflow harness
Failure modes
  • · File conflicts if fix groups overlap
  • · Agent returns data not matching schema → structured rejection
Trust signals
  • · Structured schema enforcement
  • · Explicit concurrency isolation (disjoint files/resources)