Structure Debate Arguments

argumentation-frameworkskillsetup L1937
revfactory/harness-100
What it does

Structure debate arguments using Toulmin model and evidence classification

Best for

constructing rebuttals in policy debates

Inputs
  • · claim text
  • · evidence list
  • · counter-arguments
Outputs
  • · structured Toulmin arguments
  • · rebuttal strategies
Preconditions

Debate resolution and evidence sources identified

Failure modes
  • · Weak evidence cited
  • · Logical fallacy undetected
  • · Qualifier omitted
Trust signals
  • · Toulmin model with 6 elements
  • · Evidence pyramid and quality checklist
  • · Rebuttal type matrix