Assess evidence quality

Evaluate evidence quality and assess claim credibility

Assessing research claims and evaluating expert disagreement when stakes are high

• · claim to verify
• · evidence sources
• · domain context

• · credibility rating
• · evidence strength
• · missing evidence flags
• · confidence interval

• · claim is testable or evidence exists

• · Absence of evidence treated as evidence of absence
• · Single study over-weighted vs meta-analysis

• · Study design quality (RCT > observational)
• · Sample size and statistical power
• · Publication bias risk
• · Conflict of interest declared
• · Replication rate